Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagEkaterina
Modal verbs in English oughtn`t to + Perf.Inf, shouldn`t +Perf.Inf and needn`t +Perf .Inf have the same meaning- undesirable action has happened. What difference is between them? Explain, please)

Answers · 6

1
Shouldn't + Perfect infinitive and oughtn't to + Perfect infinitive show that an action has been carried out though it was undesirable. Needn't + Perfect infinitive indicates that an action has been carried out though it was unnecessary.
1
'Needn't have done' and 'shouldn't have done' have different meanings. You needn't have done that = You did something that wasn't necessary For example, if you rushed to the station to catch your train and then found out that the departure was delayed, you might say 'I needn't have rushed'. You shouldn't have done that = Your decision to do that was a bad one For example, imagine you've spent all your money on an expensive pair of shoes that hurt your feet, and now you have no money left. You now regret buying the shoes, and say 'I shouldn't have bought those shoes'. In theory, 'oughtn't to' has the same meaning as 'shouldn't', but in practice it is rarely used, and almost never used in the past tense. You can forget about 'oughtn't' in this case.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today