Search from various English teachers...
China flagC-duo
'more than a century of debate' or ‘a debate of more than a century’? The original sentence is : 'more than a century of debate has occurred.' When I look at the structure of this sentence, I come to a short form of this sentence 'a century has occurred'. It doesn't sound right to me. But 'a debate has occurred' does make sense. For the above reason, my question arose. Would 'A debate of more than one century has occurred' make more sense?

Answers · 6

1
Your first answer is correct. 'More than a century of debate has occurred'. While the second sentence does still makes sense, we English would never word it in that way. The simplest way to explain this is probably like this, generally whenever we refer to a time span in the past when describing a noun, the time span comes before the noun. This isn't a solid rule in English, it's just common practice, but most people would choose to write it like your first answer. Although I would point out that both sentences are peculiar, because you wouldn't usually use the verb 'occurred' to descried something that didn't happen quickly.
0
The original sentence is correct. I want to say that in the sentence 'more than a century of debate has occurred' - 'debate' is an uncountable noun. In your example, 'a debate has occurred' - 'debate' is a countable noun. Your short form of 'more than a century has occurred' is also correct grammatically. The reason its hard to understand why it is correct is because 'to occur' would normally describe something happening fast or quickly, not something really long like a century! But the reason we can use it for century is because we are talking about history. We are making all those 100 years of debates and discussions into something very simply described 'as one thing'. I'm not sure if my answer makes sense, and I'm sure someone can explain better, but the important thing is: the structure is correct!
0
Both sound fine. However I would want to know the context before saying more. Neither is a conman sentence in everyday speaking. It sounds like something a news reporter would say.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today