Search from various English teachers...
Egypt flagMohamed
What is the correct (.... ; however, ....) , (.... ; however, ....) , or (.... ; however, ....)? For example, which of these sentences is correct? People say that animals in zoos are protected and served; however, others say that keeping them in zoos is cruel. People say that animals in zoos are protected and served, however, others say that keeping them in zoos is cruel. People say that animals in zoos are protected and served, however others say that keeping them in zoos is cruel.

Answers · 2

2
1 is OK and is the formal option. However, the semi-colon breaks up the flow of the ideas which, as they are closely related, is not necessary. If you had continued with a third clause (after "cruel"), then a semi-colon would have made the structure more manageable. 2 and 3 are also OK and most people would probably choose one or other of them. Many style experts consider it bad style to have two commas surrounding one word and I would agree with that view. I would keep only the comma which represented a pause for breath, which in this case, is the first one. Perhaps "well looked after"? "Serve" is a strange word in this context, and in fact has a secondary meaning in the context of animal breeding, which is not intended here.
0
(Well, I'm not sure about the "served" choice of word, but I don't that's what you're asking about.) If what follows the "however" is an independent clause (i.e. could be a sentence in its own right), and that whole clause is modified by the "however", then (a) the "however" should be set off by a comma (or commas if in the middle of the clause), and (b) that independent clause should be separated from any others by a semicolon or full stop (a.k.a. "period"). This is the situation you have here, and so you can do any of the following: "People say that animals in zoos are protected; however, others say that keeping them in zoos is cruel." "People say that animals in zoos are protected. However, others say that keeping them in zoos is cruel." "People say that animals in zoos are protected; others, however, say that keeping them in zoos is cruel." "People say that animals in zoos are protected; others say that keeping them in zoos is cruel, however." You can't use the 2nd and 3rd variants you propose. You could, however, say something like "He believes that animals in zoos are protected, however much others say that keeping them in zoos is cruel." That's because the "however" modifies the "much" rather than a whole clause (which is now no longer independent in this structure).

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today