Search from various English teachers...
Italy flagStefano
which one is correct? Hi all, I was wondering which one of the following sentences is correct, or whether both of them are right: 1- Do you have any friends on which do you most rely on? 2- Do you have any friends do you most rely on? Basically, I'd like to know whether in the first sentence "... ON which ... rely ON" can be considered as an iterance that makes the sentence wrong, since "on" is an actual part of the verb and doesn't need to be repeated with "on which". Thanks in advance!

Answers · 15

2
Both wrong, I'm afraid, for various reasons: 1) It doesn't matter whether or not you consider 'on' to be part of the verb - the point is that you only say it once. You can use a more formal construction and put 'on' in the middle of the sentence before 'which', or you can use a more everyday conversational construction and put it at the end. You can't have it twice in the sentence, though. Note that if you use the formal construction, it should by 'friend on whom you rely'. 'Which' is not used for people. 2) The 'Do you' construction is only for the interrogative form, and it has to come at the beginning of the question. You can't embed it in a question as you have done in the second version. 3) There is a mismatch between 'Do you have any...?' ( a general idea/yes or no question ) and the superlative form of 'most rely on' ( a specific idea). So you can say either 'Who are the friends that you most rely on?' This is a specific query , asking you to specify which friends they are. or 'Do you have any friends that you rely on a lot/ most of the time?' This is a more open question, only requiring a yes/no answer. As for the relative pronoun in the middle, you have a choice. 'Whom' would seem overly formal unless you use the construction I suggested above. You could use 'that' as suggested, or you could use 'who'. Alternatively, you could miss out the relative altogether - it's fine to say, for example, 'Who are the friends you most rely on?' or 'Do you have any friends you rely on most of the time?'. I hope that helps.
1
You have some choices here, but neither of these work. You don't need the second "do". You you need on with "rely" but you can only use it once. However, you can either put it at the beginning of a relative clause after "friends" or at the end. Putting "on" at the beginning would usually be seen as a formal usage, and perhaps not the most natural for a conversational question. But let's pretend it is formal, and so you have a preposition ("on") immediately preceding the relative pronoun, in which case "whom" is the usual choice in this construction. The whole thing would be "Do you have any friends on whom you most rely?" But given it's conversational, an informal register is really called for, and then the "on" of rely goes to the end. It is no longer preceding the relative pronoun, and in this case, "who" is more usual than "whom": "Do you have any friends who you most rely on?" In that formulation, you can also substitute "that" for the pronoun, or elide it completely, which is the most colloquial. Also, again to be colloquial, you may also change the adverb around a bit: "Do you have any friends you rely on the most?"
1
I have heard English speakers from the UK say "friends on whom you can rely on". But that way of saying it sounds very odd to me because I'm an American. As an American, I would say: 1- Do you have any friends who you rely on most? 2- Do you have any friends who you most rely on? Colloquially, English speakers (in America) often replace 'who' with 'that' in this instance. For example, I would say "Do you have any friends... THAT you rely on most/THAT you most rely on"
1
Hi, I would say: Do you have any friends you could rely on?

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today