Search from various English teachers...
[Deleted]
は、が? は、が? I've read many explanations but still do not have a clue what is the difference and when to use what. Maybe you've had the same problem and found your enlightenment? Please share

Answers · 7

3
Here's a brief introduction of は vs が. が marks the subject ("subject marker") of a sentence like in other languages. - くるまが くる: A car is coming. (no special connotation but a simple factual statement) は is "topic marker", but it often doubles up as the subject of a sentence as well. When the subject is marked with は, it has the connotation of expounding it, drawing the listener's attention to say more about it. - わたしは せいとです: I am a student. (a nuance of a new discourse on わたし with more to come) は can also start a compound sentence which employs a full [subject+predicate] clause. - わたしは せが たかい: As for me, my stature is high (describes わたし using a full clause せが たかい) (わたし: topic as well as subject of main clause, せ: subject of subordinate clause) To say the same thing in English, one would use "As for me, ..." which starts to talk about "me". So we can say が brings focus to the noun it marks, while は directs attention to what comes after it. は is often used to make a statement of contrast. - かれは がっこうへ いったが わたしは いえに きた: He went to school but I came home. The topic and subject marker can also work together to form a sub-main compound statement. - かれが きた とき わたしは ねていた. When he came, I was sleeping. (typical subordinate and main clause arrangement: が in sub-clause, は in main) In a discourse, が tends to introduce a new subject, which corresponds to the use of indefinite article "a" in English. は statement(s) then says more about the new subject, as one would do using the definite article "the" in English. 1. 昨晩火事が起きた: A fire broke out last night. (が corresponds to "A") 2. その火は大きな被害をもたらした: The fire caused a great damage. (は to "The") (#1 introduces a brand new subject, a fire, and #2 gives more detail about it) So one can say は takes the center stage, and が has a supporting role.
1
Hi Iwan, I wrote a blog post about it here. http://www.japaneserabbit.com/#!は-or-が/c218b/561ad7130cf2c3576e58661a Hope it helps.
1
I've been doing Japanese for like 4-5 years now and I know i could not explain any of better than a lot of them out there. My advice as long as you generally get the meanings is to not dwell too much on it. A feel for which is used when will come over time from exposure content reading/hearing sentences seeing when natives use which when etc.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today