Search from various English teachers...
United Kingdom flagJessica
Particles (Japanese ) びょうきになりましたか。 Why is に used rather than が? よろしくお願いします。

Answers · 8

2
it's a fixed usage. nalu has different meanings. When it refers to "become" or any verb around it, ni is used. eg. haluni nalu. it becomes spring. bangaosini nalu. she becomes a nurse
2
びょうき means "sickness" or "state of being unhealthy, ill". に is the particle signifying "in", "a", "into", "to", or "toward". なりました is "became..."、fall into certain state". So it's "I fell in illness", with "I" omitted since it is obvious as in typical Japanese phrases. If you use びょうきが, it won't jibe with なりました, so you must use a different verb. For example, びょうきが きました。(Illness came upon me).
1
I agree with the two members, びょうきになる is an expression for "to become sick / to be in a situation of not being fine", or "state changes from being fine to not being fine". We use に with なる, for example, わたしはせんせいになります / かれはいしゃ(doctor)になりました / かのじょはげんきになりました, sometimes memorize verb + particle (without thinking too much) is needed. For us, it always happens, for example, "get up, get along with, get on, get off, etc". If I separate these expressions in each words, it doesn't make sence, does it? So, there are so many things that we simply have to memorize when we study language(s). I hope this was helpful.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today