Is "of" used only for nouns and the genitive is used for people and animals?
My english workbook says "Scientist, with the help of volunteers, study animals in their natural environment."
I always tought "of" is used when we say about posseson of nouns for example
the top of the mountain, the colour of the car etc.
And we use genitive ('s) for people and animals
cat's milk
my mom's car.
Why then don't we say "Scietists with the volunteers' help" ?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 7
1
Hi! In English, you can use "of" or " 's" to show possession. They are more or less interchangeable. It's okay to say "the car's color". The reason they used "help of volunteers" is because in verbal English, it's easier to distinguish that there are multiple volunteers written in that context, rather than saying "volunteers' help". This is because "volunteers' (possssive) and "volunteers (plural)" sound the exact same aloud. I hope that helps!
0
I think you're holding on to a rather simplified rule. It works fine at elementary level, but you're clearly above that, so of course you're running into "exceptions".
Just follow and accept clear, good examples (which is what we native speakers do), and you'll do fine.
0
The others have made good points, and I would just like to point out that in your example, the volunteers are somewhat "depersonified." The idea is that the scientists are using the help of the volunteers as a tool, and that the volunteers are not really directing the experiments — the scientists are. Also, notice that "help" is definite, but "volunteers" is not — the construction with "of" serves to clarify this.
0
John's abilities to do this task are the best. = The abilities of John to do this task are the best. John's mother is here. = The mother of John is here. Context will determine which construction is best.
0
You could say "with volunteers' help" (not "the volunteers' help")
or
"with help from volunteers"
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
