enjoys or enjoyed?
What should I use , enjoys or enjoyed, in the following context?
"He told me he also enjoys/enjoyed working with computer." (talking about his present interest)
Is it even possible to use present tense in an indirect speech?
Thank you so much!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 20
2
Either verb form is possible:
"He told me he also enjoys working with computers."
"He told me he also enjoyed working with computers."
If you are doing an exercise in reported speech, you should use the second form to show that you can do the 'back shift' in tenses. However, it is also correct to use the present tense if this fact is still true now.
But, as you can see, the problem with your sentence is not the verb, but the noun. 'Computer' is a countable noun, and - as I'm sure you have learnt - you can't use a singular countable noun without an article or other determiner.
You are talking about computers in general, so you have to use a plural noun: computers.
1
Reported speech in past tenses:
When the reporting verb is in the simple past tense (e.g. said,told,explained,etc.), the tenses of the original statement has to be changed, UNLESS the statement is still true at the time of reporting it or it is a general statement (e.g. He said that the sun rises from the East.):
Simple present changes to Simple past:
"I always DRINK coffee." = She said that she always DRANK coffee. / She said that she always drinks coffee. (because she always drinks coffee, it is a habit that she still has at the time I am reporting her statement, so you may keep the simple present form "drinks" despite the reporting verb being in the simple past form)
Present continuous changes to Past continuous
"I AM READING a book" = He explained that he WAS READING a book.
Simple past changes to Past perfect
"Bill ARRIVED on Saturday" = He said that Bill HAD ARRIVED on Saturday.
Present perfect changes to Past perfect
"I HAVE BEEN to Spain" = He told me that he HAD BEEN to Spain.
Past perfect remains as Past perfect
"I HAD just TURNED out the light" = He explained that he HAD just TURNED out the light.
Present perfect continuous changes to Past perfect continuous
"We HAVE BEEN WAITING for hours" = They complained that they HAD BEEN WAITING for hours.
Past continuous changes to Past perfect continuous
"We WERE LIVING in Paris" = They told me that they HAD BEEN LIVING in Paris.
Simple future changes to Present conditional
"I WILL BE in Geneva on Monday" = He said that he WOULD BE in Geneva on Monday.
Future continuous changes to Conditional continuous
"I WILL BE USING the car next Friday" = She said that she WOULD BE USING the car next Friday.
Modal verbs in original statements that do not change in reported speech: might, could, would, should, ought to:
"This COULD be a prank." = She said that this COULD be a prank. / She says that this COULD be a prank.
"I SHOULD leave now." = He said that he SHOULD leave now / He says that he SHOULD leave now.
1
He told me he also enjoyed working with computer.
1
"computers" - plural
Both options are possible and both would mean that he enjoyed / enjoys working with computers regularly.
If he meant that he enjoyed working with computers during a specific period of time in the past, then the simple past is the only correct option.
1
Here's more info! I'll have to break this up into 2 separate answers because it's too long hahaha
Reported speech in present tenses:
The present tenses of the original statement can be kept in their original forms:
When the reporting verb is in the present simple tense (e.g. says/tells/explains/etc.)
present simple: "I LIKE rock music!" = She SAYS that she really LIKES rock music.
present continuous: "She IS WORKING" = He TELLS me that she IS WORKING. (reporting verb "tells" is in present simple, so you keep the original statement's tense, which is the present continuous "is working". The same applies for the previous example and the following two.)
present perfect: "He HAS BEEN here for an hour." = She EXPLAINS that he HAS BEEN here for an hour.
present perfect continuous: "They HAVE SEEN this picture." = He SAYS that they HAVE SEEN this picture.
Exception: when the original statement is in past tenses and your reporting verb is in in simple present tense, keep the original tenses of the statement:
"I used to play hockey." = He says that he used to play hockey.
"I had already left when she came." = He says that he had already left when she came.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
