Search from various English teachers...
Croatia flagmjehur
you look good Why do we hear in movies 'You look good' or 'I feel fine' when this feeling/looking good is taking place at that exact moment, I mean why not present continuous instead? What rule or what exception of a rule takes effect here? (and also, is this formulation of the question grammatically correct?)

Answers · 11

2
Actually, we can use both! How do you feel? I am feeling good/I feel good The continuous version of this seems a little more unnatural to me. " I feel good" is more natural for a native, but both are correct. There is no rule to it.
2
With STATIVE verbs (look,feel,appear,seem etc) we don't usually use present progressive.This is not ALWAYS but usually the case. http://www.perfect-english-grammar.com/stative-verbs.html So we say "I believe" not "I am believing" ,"I love" not "I am loving" etc.
0
I agree with Ruthi - the rule is knowing what a stative verb is, and what a dynamic verb is (the terminology might be different between textbooks, but the classification is the same). I've seen students skip or ignore this rule, and it leads to them using present continuous for every verb - which sounds unnatural - when native speakers will follow the stative verb rule. There is an exception, which it uses the present continuous sense of "at this exact moment now" or "temporarily". It can even mean "irritatingly". So yes, you can shift a stative verb into a continuous sense, but you need an exact reason to do so. It doesn't work automatically. eg: You are unreasonable. (general statement of fact) You're being unreasonable. (So please stop that!) Students are taught this at upper-intermediate level... after they have a clear understanding of stative verbs. ;)

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today