Past simple VS Past perfect
Hello Gurus of English. I have a question to ask. There are events in a chronological order. Event 1, Event 2, Event 3, Event 4. When the Past Simple tense is used everithing is clear.
I had Even 1 we had Event 2 we had Event 3 and finally We had Event 4.
Assuming we start describing Event 4 and after that Even 3 and after that Event 2 and finally Event 1, we have to use the Past Perfect tence.
I had had Event 4, but before I had had Event 3, and before I had had Event 2 and before the previous one I had had Event 1.
The best way is the Present Simple. It is set in stone, BUT if we forget something and need to add information, what should we do?
I had Event 1 and after that we had Event 4. The order is unchronological and I have to use the Past perfect tence. I had Event 1 and Event 4, but before Event 4 I had had Event 2 and I had had Event 3. In a case of Event 3, do I have to use Past Simple or Past Perfect? (I had Event 1, Event 4, but before Event 4 I had had 2 and had 3)
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
1
I agree with Su.Ki. and Alex - we need a concrete example. However, I'll try to answer your actual question...
"BUT if we forget something and need to add information, what should we do?"
We say, "(but) before that," then follow with a past simple statement.
Past perfect is more than simply re-ordering events. Perhaps that's what's confusing you.
0
Ok. I met Mary in my friend's flat five years ago. We decided to drink a cup of coffee in a restraunt and after that we went to a cinema, but after the cinema we met her husband. What a pity.
The order is chronological. The Present simple tense is required. It's clear-cut.
I met Mary's husband. We had gone to a cinema together, but before we had drunk a cup of coffee and I had met her in a flat of my friend.
The order is unchronological. The Past perfect tense is required.
I was with Mary and we come across her husband. Afterwards I have two possible variants.
1. I met Mary and we come across her husband. We had drunk a cup of coffee, we had gone to a cinema together.
2. I met Mary and we come across her husband. We had drunk a cup of coffee, we went to a cinema together.
0
I agree with Su.Ki. -- this is too difficult to work with. Try some example sentences, rather than event 1, event 2, event 3, etc.
0
Please give us some concrete example! Even we gurus find it difficult to get our heads round all these theoretical events.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
