Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagAlexander
mental verbs in the continious tense Hello Gurus of English.I have a question to ask. Mental verbs are believed to have not been used in continious tences except of "I am thinking of doing" and I am used to dealing with it, but yesterday I was told about additional structures. 1. People are wanting a better level of service therse days. 2. I am sorry, I am forgetting my manners. Please, have a seat. Are there rules to follow or common exception to comprehend? By and large, what is a difference between " People want a better level..." and "People are wanting a better level..'? In the Second point, Why cannot we use "I am sorry, I have forgotten my manners. Please, have a seat"? What do we want to point out when when we use mental verbs in the continious tense? With all my respect Alexander Potapov.

Answers · 2

3
Yes, there is a difference, and this is where intermediate/upper-level students fall off the wagon. After telling learners that mental verbs (we also call them stative/static verbs) aren't used in continuous tense, later on - surprise! - we suddenly say it's possible. If the students haven't been paying attention, they assume they can put any verb in continuous tense after all. Bad idea. Continuous tense indicates a temporary state. For your first example, "people want..." is a general statement of fact. "People are wanting..." tells us that this hasn't always been the case, and the situation may change in the near future. We can also use continuous tense to present a mental verb as annoying or unwanted - again, the indication of a temporary situation. "I'm forgetting my manners" tells me that you find it unacceptable and you will rectify the problem. I [ forget / have forgotten / forgot ] my manners sound as if you really don't care about your lack of manners. I hope that helps a bit!
0
I'm no expertby no means.but thereis no real difference. If you were to say: "I am sorry, I am forgetting my manners. Please, have a seat" Or "I am sorry, I have forgotten my manners. Please, have a seat"? To me as a native I would see no difference. If you want to get technical, "forgetting" is more present progressive verb, whilst "forgotten" impiles past verb. BUT TO SOUND MORE NATURAL... I would say "I'm sorry, WHERE are my manners? Please take a seat". So your basically stating you HAVE manners, but just briefly forgot about them. Hope this helps

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today