What r different between present perfect and present perfect continues????
now i'm learning about it but i'm so confused
What r different between present perfect and present perfect continues????
for example "How long have you been studying German?" is right.
but i think "How long have you studied German?"is also right?
what r different????
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
2
There is no difference in meaning between these two sentences. The verb 'to study' already implies an activity of some duration.
However, there are other verbs which require the present perfect continuous in this context. For example, you could not say "how long have you read this book?" or "how long have you watched this film?". In these cases you would need to use the present perfect continous: "how long have you been reading this book?" or "how long have you been watching this film?"
To be on the safe side, it is best to use the present perfect continuous (rather than the present perfect) whenever you are describing the duration of an activity which started in the past and still continues in the present. The exceptions, of course, are the verbs 'to be' and 'to have'. 'To be' has no continuous form, and the continuous form of 'to have' is not used except in certain contexts.
1
Both sentences are the same and are correct. If you wanted to give the idea of completion, you would ask, "How long did you study German?". "Have you been studying" suggests the studying activity is still occurring. "Have studied" is a little more vague in suggesting the studying could be in the past or it could be still underway.
1
Yeah as Michael says both are correct.
In a way the first one asks "How long has it been since you started and then continued to study German?" while the second one asks "How long have you studied German for up until this point in time".
So it is two ways of asking the same thing.
1
What is the difference between the "present perfect" and the "present perfect continuous" ?
Both your sentences are correct English sentences.
The present perfect simple gives the idea of completion.
Your second sentence "How long have you studied German?" has the word "studied" which suggests completion.
The present perfect continuous suggests that something is unfinished.
The first sentence has the word "studying" which is a present activity.
However although technically your sentences are different, in everyday use, most English speakers would not understand them to convey different things, and they could be used interchangeably.
However if you had said "How long had you studied German?", an English speaker would immediately know that you are talking about something that is finished, because had is the past tense.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
