Search from various English teachers...
South Korea flagHwaok
What r different between present perfect and present perfect continues???? now i'm learning about it but i'm so confused What r different between present perfect and present perfect continues???? for example "How long have you been studying German?" is right. but i think "How long have you studied German?"is also right? what r different????

Answers · 3

1
1) I believe it's more difficult to explain grammar of your native language because normally you just know that this is right and that is wrong and don't stop to think why. so I'll give it a try too )) 2) hope for corrections and/or comments on my reply from native English speakers! thank you. Present Perfect focuses on the result of the process; Present Perfect Continuous focuses on the process itself. - Your German is excellent, how long have you studied it? - Oh, you are flattering me. I've spent three years and a half on it. Honestly speaking, the result could have been much better... you think of the result here. it does not matter for you whether your addressee will continue his(her) studying or not; any details of the process of studying are not that important as well. you kind of stress that there is a result of this process (the knowledge of German), and that the process is completed - at least a certain part of it, so that you can see a result already. and you might want to know how long it would take for you to get the same result. - Seems that you've spent so much time on your German, exactly how long have you been studying it? - Since I found out that I have relatives in Austria. It was in April 2007, if I'm not mistaken. you focus on the process, you are expecting to get some details about the process. you might want to know when the process was started and if it still continues; or whether it was difficult for your addressee or not; or what was behind the decision to start this process and so on. the result (good or bad knowledge of German) is out of focus right now. would be glad if this helped ~
1
You use the present perfect simple when the action is finished: Sam has repaired his car. It goes all right now => The car is repaired. It works fine. You can drive it. You use the present perfect continuous when the action is not over yet: Sam has been repairing his car. He's got oil on his hands. => The car is not necessarily repaired. I studied German for 10 years. (I do not study German any more) I have been studying German for 10 years (I am still studying German)
1
yes - both sentences are OK. There are just slight differences in meaning. If you ask "How long have you been studying German?", you expect that the person might continue studying German in the future. If you ask "How long have you studied German?", you don't necessarily expect them to study more. also, "How long have you been studying German?" might mean "how long since you started studying", while "How long have you studied German?" might refer to the total time spent studying.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today