I used to be an ogre. ("Shrek Forever After")
What does it mean? "I was an ogre"? These phrases are the same or there are differences?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 6
4
You'd be unlikely to say 'I was an ogre' as a statement on its own. You'd say this along with some kind of time phrase or other qualification. Shrek might say 'I was an ogre a few years ago, but then I changed ...' But if he says 'I used to be an ogre', then that tells the whole story - he was an ogre once, but he isn't one any more.
So, to answer your question, no, they aren't exactly the same, because the 'used to' phrase gives more information.
2
Both "I was an ogre" and "I used to be an ogre" are correct, but they have slightly different meanings. The example you gave is kind of tough to explain so I'll start with a simpler one:
"I was a jerk when I broke up with my girlfriend by texting her." That tells me in that moment, you were a jerk. But it doesn't tell me anything else because I don't know if this is something you always did, or if it was just a one-time thing, or something you did just with her.
Jerk = a rude, insensitive guy - the kind of person who would break up with someone by texting her. Women can be jerks too, but usually called something different that I won't repeat here.
"I used to be a jerk, and then I met my future wife." That tells me that before you met your wife, you were a rude, insensitive guy but she helped you become a better person.
I would say, "He was a jerk!" to express that someone acted rudely and insensitively to me, and he's likely to do that again to someone else.
I would say, "He used to be a jerk. . ." to express that someone is much more polite and sensitive today than he was in the past. Even if I don't say "but now he is not a jerk" it's implied. And the next question is likely to be, "What do you think has changed?"
I'm not familiar with the exact reference from Shrek, but here is how I would interpret the two sentences.
"I was an ogre." Shrek is saying that at one point in the past, he was an ogre - and we don't know if that was for five minutes or five years. It's just a simple statement of fact.
"I used to be an ogre" (but then something happened) Shrek is saying that in the past, he was an ogre but today, he is not an ogre. He says it this way to make me wonder what changed to stop him from being an ogre.
1
Hi,
They mean the same thing; that the person was once an ogre but they are not now.
Hope this helps :)
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
