Search from various English teachers...
India flagSudeep
Me vs I Today i really got confused when i was asked the question, Which one is more appropriate, I am older than her/she. What i think is that "than " as a preposition requires its complement to be in the objective case i.e. me should be correct but there's another angle to it,than as a conjunction is also used which makes the whole sentence an elliptical sentence i.e I am older than she [is]. Which should i mark as a correct answer?Is it about archaic usage of elliptical sentence which makes it obsolete or less appropriate?

Answers · 13

1
Can I just add something here? Here's a conversation A: Is 'I'm older than she' a grammatically correct form? B: Yes, it is. A: Does anybody ever say this? B: No. I've never heard a native speaker use this form. I've never seen this in a book that's less than 50 years old. A: So what do native speakers say? B: We say 'I'm older than her.' A: But that's wrong, isn't it? You need a subject pronoun, not an object pronoun B: Err ........ technically, yes. But that's what everyone says. A: So 'she' is right, but nobody says it, and 'her' is wrong but everybody says it? B: Yup.That's about it. A: So what should I do? I need a sentence that's right, but also one which English speakers actually use. B: Umm ..... how about 'I'm older than she is'. That gets round the problem. A: Great! Thanks!
1
I also agree with Kapil that "than" is a conjunction. Than is quite in a debate by grammarians. "Than she" is considered preferable in traditional grammar. The quick answer is both are correct, but not everyone agrees that both are correct. These days, the word than is classified both as a conjunction and as a preposition, and that has been the root of the debate. The safest option is to expand the words after than. This usually means adding at least the verb (e.g., than she is / than they have). I am older than she. (correct formal usage) I am older than she is. (expanded: ) I am older than her. (common informal usage) I hope this helps. * To everyone, feel free to comment and correct. I got some of the info from grammar sites.
1
AFAIK 'than' as a conjunction is more standard. Using objective pronouns can sometimes change the meaning completely. A famous example :- Do you like chocolate more than me? => Do you like chocolate more than (you like) me? Do you like chocolate more than I? => Do you like chocolate more than I (do / like chocolate)? My vote goes to - "I am older than she".
0
SHE is a pronoun, used to represent a female person or animal that has already been mentioned. • Susan was tired. SHE wanted to sleep. HER is the possessive form of she. It is also used as the object of a verb and as the object of a preposition. • The book is Susan’s. It is HERS (possessive). • Give HER the book (object of a verb). • Give it to HER (object of a preposition).
0
Appropriate sentence: I am older than her.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today