Search from various English teachers...
China flagFrank
Are both OK? What's the difference? Who would put an empty milk carton back in the fridge? (talking about the past) Who would have put an empty milk carton back in the fridge? ( talking about the past)

Answers · 6

3
I agree with Conner. The first phrase might be used if you found the empty carton in the fridge, and didn't really want to know who placed it there, but wanted to complain/comment about the act itself. For context, imagine walking and finding a pile of trash in the middle of the sidewalk... you might say in a disappointed or disgusted manner, "who would leave this trash on the sidewalk?" but you actually don't really want to know what person left the trash. Instead you're expressing dissatisfaction with the act itself. For the second phrase, imagine that you received a gift from a secret admirer... in this case, you would surely want to know who left the gift and you might say, "who would have left this gift for me?" I hope this helps!
2
In my opinion "who would" makes it sound more like "WHY would someone do such a thing?" but "who would have" makes it sound like "I wonder who did this?"

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today