why is my answer wrong?
The Sahara marathon
It began in 1986 and now attracks about 2 hundred runners, the majority of _________ ages range from seventeen to forty seven.
The book answer is "whose", but I wrote down "their".
Could "their" be possible?
Thank you!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 8
3
In this case, I think "whose" is more appropriate because it's a relative pronoun, whereas "their" is an adjective.
We could also write: "It began in 1986 and now attracks about 2 hundred runners. The majority of their ages range from seventeen to forty seven", but you must separate the two sentences.
2
No, "their" is only possible if you write a separate sentence.
"It began in 1986 and now attracts about 2 hundred runners. The majority of their ages range from seventeen to forty seven."
Because the last part is a relative clause, you need to use "whose" (in this case).
1
"Whose" is possessive (singular) while "their" is possessive in plural form. Generally speaking, you are referring to each person as one (who, whose) instead of as a group (they, their). In this case, if you use "their" in plural, you're implying that each one has more than one age.
1
I would say that your answer is not wrong-- but the way that many multiple choice questions work is that they take the best answer as the right answer. If you use 'whose' then the last part of the sentence would be a subordinate clause to the main clase. If you use 'their' then the last part of the sentence is an independent clause. It could stand as a separate sentence, and it would seem more natural if it did stand as a separate sentence, rather than link it to the first part of the sentence with a comma.
Also, I would say that your word "attracks" is a little interesting. It should be 'attracts', but 'attracks' makes sense in its own non-standard way, since you are talking about a race, and races are often run on tracks, or at least the runners make tracks. The prefix 'at' shows a going toward. So "going toward a track or tracks" is the meaning you wanted to convey-- why not?
0
Where did that sentence come from?
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
