Search from various English teachers...
France flagli_qin
intransitive or transitive verb ? [she is going to fall for that old trick...] I really need help with this sentence : 'You are crazy if you think she is going to fall for that old trick.' I wonder here why we have an intransitive prepositionnal verb, is 'that old trick' not an equivalent for a direct object ? Thank you.

Answers · 4

2
I don't know the big words in grammar, but I think this is intransitive because she can't fall THE trick, but rather she is falling. It is someting that happens to her, nothing happens to the trick. It is due to the trick that she falls, but she does not do anything to the trick. You cannot fall something, you can only fall. You can fall due to something, but you cannot fall something. But again, I am not a grammatician, maybe someone else has a better grammatical knowledge and can explain better or correct.
1
I fully agree with Lydia. "... is 'that old trick' not an equivalent for a direct object?" Well, my question is, how can it be? "Fall" is an intransitive verb. Who falls? She does. Even if we ignore the rules, remove "for" and force "fall" to be transitive, then we have a stranger situation. "She is going to fall that old trick" means the old trick falls, not her. It's simply a strange image, even if we do ignore the clumsy sentence.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today