Same-time action: with doing?
It sounds pretty basic but I wonder what is the most common expression to describe same-time action?
I was reading a book (main clause)
I had some coffee (subordinate clause)
I was reading a book with having some coffee. (maybe it's the best?)
I was reading a book (,) having some coffee. (I've generally used this)
I was reading a book and had some coffee. (for me sounds a little bit weird to contain two different time tense in one sentence)
I had some coffee while reading a book. (sounds perfect, but the main and subordinate are replaced with each other)
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 2
0
I was reading a book, while drinking (having) some coffee, would be the best way to say it. Switching the clauses also works, and sounds quite natural.
The first sentence, "I was reading a book with having some coffee," is not right because you wouldn't say "with having." You could say "...a book, with coffee," but it wouldn't be quite right.
"I was reading a book, having coffee," is just fine, but it sounds a little incomplete, like the sentence would go on after that (e.g. I was reading a book, having some coffee, when a raccoon ran in the door wearing a top hat.)
"I was reading a book and had some coffee," sounds alright, but it sort of implies that you had the coffee later, or that you had it with you but weren't drinking it.
0
The most natural would be:
- I was reading a book while/whilst having some coffee (or "While I was having some having coffee, I was reading a book").
-I was reading a book as I was having some coffee (or "As I was having some coffee, I was reading a book").
I was reading a book with having some coffee. - Incorrect
I was reading a book, having some coffee. -Extremely awkward. You would never hear this except in poetry.
I was reading a book and had some coffee - Incorrect, because the tenses don't match
I was reading a book and having some coffee - Correct
I read a book and had some coffee -Correct
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
