Search from various English teachers...
United States flagToabin
When is it okay to use 了 and 没有 in a sentence? 你大学毕业了没有? I saw this sentence in a book. The sentence means "Have you graduated from university?". Why does the sentence with a negative 没有 use 了 instead of 过?Also, why does 没有 appear at the end of the sentence instead of before 毕业? Lastly, why does the main noun, 大学, appear after the verb, 毕业?

Answers · 11

3
As you know, in negative sentences, "了" is not used with "没有". So you cannot say "我大学还没有毕业了". Instead, you should say "我大学还没有毕业". However, "你大学毕业了没有" is NOT a negative sentence, but a question, which is equal to "你大学毕业了吗". Here are some other examples: 你吃饭了没有? = 你吃饭了吗? 你结婚了没有? = 你结婚了吗? It should be noted that if you need to use "不" rather than "没有" to answer a question, this question must not end with "没有". e.g. 你明天来吗? You cannot say "你明天来没有?", which is grammatically incorrect. "Lastly, why does the main noun, 大学, appear after the verb, 毕业?" I think you meant to say "Lastly, why does the main noun, 大学, appear BEFORE the verb, 毕业?" There is no special reason for it. We always say "大学/中学/小学毕业" instead of "毕业大学/中学/小学".
1
1、The sentence means "Have you graduated from university?" 是的。是这个意思,但还有一个意思在里面:"have you still leant in the school?",可以说"没有"这个词语问的就是这个意思。 2、 Why does the sentence with a negative 没有 use 了 instead of 过? 你的这个问题主要是问:为什么不用“过”,你大学毕业过了?这句话是不对的, 因为一个人大学毕业只有一次,所以只能用“了”,你大学毕业了吗? 3、why does 没有 appear at the end of the sentence instead of before 毕业? 因为“没有”出现在“毕业”之前,句子意思就不同了,你大学没有毕业? 更侧重于表达:你还在学校学习。 4、why does the main noun, 大学, appear after the verb, 毕业? 因为“大学”做限定成分,所以放在动词毕业的前面。如果没有“大学”,句子“你毕业了没有? ”,意思不明白,你要问小学?大学?高中?大学?研究生?硕士? “你毕业大学了没有?”这个句子是错的。
1
It does not use 过 because 过 means to have experienced something. 没有 comes at the end because it is a way of forming a question. If 没有 went before 毕业, it would read 你没有毕业了大学。 This would be incorrect and would not be a question. As for your last question, read the sentence again, it says 你大学毕业了没有?大学 is before 毕业, not after it.
0
As far as I recall, 了 has two uses: past tense and change of state. So if, for example, you wanted to say your lamp is broken, you'd say 我的檯燈壞了; not because it was in the past, but because it was working before and its new state is "broken". Likewise, "graduated" is a state of being, therefore 了 is required.
0
It's hard to explain it in words.You can contact me.My major is teaching Chinese. [email protected]

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today