Search from various English teachers...
China flagWu Ting
How would you explain “if” and “that” in this sentence? I spent a lot of time trying to identify the exact point at which I noticed a change in Murph, somehow thinking that if I could figure out where he had begun to slide down the curve of the bell that I could do something about it. How would you explain “if” in “somehow thinking that if I could figure out…”Does it mean the usual meaning of if? Or does it mean whether? And How would you explain “that” in “that I could do something about it”? Thanks!

Answers · 7

1
I think that you have made a very important point. That author has had his book published, and I have never had a book published. But it is my (very) humble opinion that the sentence is poorly written. I think that it would clearer if arranged as: I spent ...in Murph, somehow thinking THAT I could do something about it if I could figure out where he had begun to slide down the curve of the bell. ("If I could ... the bell" modifies the verb "could do.") If you analyze the sentence as he has written it, then I feel that the second "that" should not be there: ...somehow thinking that -- if I could figure out where he had begun to slide down the curve of the bell -- I could do something about it. In other words, the "that" introduces "I could do something about it." "If I could figure out where he had begun to slide down the curve of the bell" is an adverbial clause and does not need to be introduced by "that."
1
A little creative use of parentheses might help here: If we seprate the component parts of the clause (which is basically a long and verbose version of the structure "to think that if X, then Y", only, however, that the author used "that" for "then"), we have "thinking that if (I could figure out where he had begun to slide down the curve of the bell) [,] that [then] I (could do something about it)." Here, X is "I could figure out where had begun to slide down the curve of the bell", and Y is "I could do something about it." Stated simply, the author is saying "I somehow thought if I could figure out when things started to go wrong, then I could do something about it."
0
Hi Gordon, "that" is commonly used after "think" and it serves to signal that you are telling me more about what you are thinking about. The phrase "think that" is used very commonly and it certain sentences, using "think" alone without "that" would sound wrong. "If" was used with its usual meaning.
0
If......., I could...... If phrase + main clause. It is the standard structure. In this case both clause are introduced with that because they connect to "thinking". Yes, you can do this in English.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today