Please, which sentence is best when writing?
1. This model is available in 3 colors: white, black, tan.
2. This model is available in 3 colors: white, black, and tan.
3. This model is available in 3 colors: white, black, or tan.
Also, can I say it in same words on a telephone?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 10
3
"1. This model is available in 3 colors: white, black, tan."
This example is missing a conjunction (e.g. 'and') before the final item. It would not be acceptable in formal writing, or in most informal writing. However, you WILL see this construction in the product descriptions of some catalogs, probably for the purposes of brevity and clarity. If you are giving a spoken description of the product, you would not use this form. You would use either #2 or #3.
"2. This model is available in 3 colors: white, black, and tan."
"3. This model is available in 3 colors: white, black, or tan."
Even without seeing the context that might include a photo of the 'model', I can conclude that you are not talking about a single model that comes in a 3-color combination of white, black and tan. If that was the case, you would simply say, This model is white, black, and tan." Just by reading this statement in the description, I know that I can get a white model, a black model, or a tan model. Therefore, either #2 or #3 would be perfectly clear to the reader.
To address the point raised by Tim regarding the last comma before the conjunction, this is called a 'serial comma'. Generally, writing style manuals in the U.S. use it, while those in the UK do not. This is not a hard-and-fast distinction, though, as newspapers usually leave it out. Sometimes, this comma is necessary to avoid confusion. I suggest you do a web search on 'serial comma' for a complete understanding. I also suggest that as an English learner in the U.S., you should use it.
3
1 is awkward and should not be used.
Either 2 or 3 would be okay in writing or over the phone and you might see both used by native speakers.
2 is actually more correct and therefore best, because the "three colors" are "white, black, AND tan."
"white, black, OR tan" is one color that you may pick from three, so is technically incorrect for the structure of the sentence, but not its meaning - "The model is available in white, black, or tan" would be fine, except, again, it is actually available in all three colors, not just one of them.
Using "or" in this context is an informal way of signaling to the reader/listener that he or she has a choice. There may be marketing reasons to do that. In that sense, 3 is not "wrong" and would certainly not sound wrong or strange to most native English speakers.
0
The third sentence is correct. Also, when using commas to separate items in a list, the last two are separated by a conjunction without a comma. "This model is available in three colors:white, black or tan."
0
The last two statements have completely different meanings. The last one is "This model is available in 3 (different) colors: white, black, or tan." but the second to last statement implies that the model is all three colours.
0
Option 2 is the most common one. Option 3 is still acceptable, but it's not something you'd expect a native speaker to say in many cases (although there are exceptions where Option 3 is superior). Option 1 is not something you'd write, simply because the end of an English list is defined by the conjunction used before the last word.
Here's an example to demonstrate what I mean by the last sentence:
"I like dogs, cats, eagles, and horses," is correct. "I like dogs, cats, eagles, horses," is not. The reason it's not is that without putting that 'and' there, the person reading or listening to the sentence is now expecting another thing you like. Putting a conjunction before the last member of a list allows the reader/listener to know that you're finished with your list.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
