Which one is correct?
I am a middle school teacher. The following is from a test with B as the right choice. I wonder why, and I think A, C and D are all right. Who can tell me the difference among them?
--____ Jacky Chan's new film?
--Yes. I ______ it last Saturday.
A. Have you seen; have seen
B. Did you see; saw
C. Have you seen; saw
D. Did you see; have seen
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
0
To provide a good explaination, let's do such a thing:
I'll start with the answer: the time expression LAST night is Past Simple.
Examples of sentences in past simple: she ate the banana...
Past simple is the verb in past form (eat-->ate; see-->saw), and that is why the sentence-completaion to the "Yes, I _____ it last night" must bee SAW: I saw it LAST night.
So option A is out (no "saw), and so is option D.
Now, this is what we have:
--____ Jacky Chan's new film?
--Yes. I ______ it last Saturday.
B. Did you see; saw
C. Have you seen; saw
If I go with C and ask "have you seen the new... film?", I will answer: "Yes, I have seen..." because the verb in the answer must match the verb in the question, and "saw" isn't good here.
So we are left with B, with is correct because, as I said - past simple (DID, SAW).
I would recommend, also, this link, it's great ! It has all the English grammar rules in a good way, you can also give it to your students:
http://www.ego4u.com/en/cram-up/grammar
Glad to help!
0
B and C both seem correct in my opinion.
0
I believe that "C" is the only "correct" answer.
We would use the present perfect in such a situation.
"A" and "D" are definitely "wrong." ("Last Saturday" requires the past "saw.")
"B" is passable and said by some native speakers. But it would not be the correct answer for an examination in "good" English.
0
Well, A and D sound better and more natural if it were only just "Yes. I have seen it." without the "-last Saturday." But even then, it sounds better if it is answered with "Yes. I saw it." so B and C seem to be the better answers; I hear both "Did you see" and "Have you seen" when talking about movies. I suppose I do hear B more frequently.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
