Is there a grammar error in the sentence "she'd had wrapped around her finger...."
Maybe she had been drinking a little more lately, but I knew that her first-year studies were incredibly stressful, even for her, and that her professors at Columbia were more demanding and less understanding than the ones she’d had wrapped around her finger at Brown.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 8
0
It is correct -- it's the past perfect passive, used here to connect the present state of affairs (tough profs at Columbia) in terms of what happened at a specified point in the past (when she had had the profs at Brown wrapped around her finger)
The expression is "to have someone wrapped around your finger"
So, in your sentence above, the syntax is re-arranged but all the parts are there:
...the ones she had had (pp of have) wrapped around her finger...
... ... ...
If the sentence above had been written as:
...the ones she had wrapped around her fingers at Brown...
that'd be PRESENT perfect passive...meaning the professors were wrapped around her finger in the past and and continuing to the present moment.
That would be wrong though because she is at Columbia now, not Brown -- so present prefect passive can't work here.
So, to sum up...
The PAST perfect passive form is used in the sentence above to make that sequence of (past) events in the right order. First (easy life at Brown) and THEN (tough profs at Columbia)
0
The paragraph is correct. In English, sometimes you will see "had had"; two hads together. It may be considered awkward by some, but it is correct in some cases, including this one.
0
Is it a past perfect passive sentence? Would it requires a "be" verb to make a "passive" tense? Where is the "be" verb?
0
It is correct. Compare the following:
She has a string wrapped around her finger.
This is the string she has (pause) wrapped around her finger.
She had a string wrapped around her finer.
This is the string she had (pause) wrapped around her finger.
She had had a string wrapped around her finger.
This is the string she had had (pause) wrapped around her finger.
As you see, the past perfect here is "had had".
"wrapped around her finger" is a qualifying clause that qualifies the string.
In your sentence she had had professors wrapped around her finger.
When a woman has a man wrapped around her finger...you get the gist.
0
does it mean she once controled or manipulated those teachers at Brown, but not any more now
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
