Logical Deduction
"She doesn't eat out."
Logical deductions for this sentence would be:
-She must eat at home.
-She can't eat out.
When you are given this sentence and there's no context, how can you really understand whether it is a deduction or obligation? Is it possible to tell when you don't have the context?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 12
4
The only thing I can logically deduce (with no context) is that she does not go to restaurants to eat. I can't say that she is not able go out - I can only be certain that she does not. It could be by choice; it could result from some physical or mental block against it; it could be that she cannot afford to go. However, I can say none of these for certain.
I can only be sure that if I visited any restaurant, I would never see her in it or any other restaurant.
2
A logical deduction would be a conclusion(s) that any reasonable person would come up with. An obligation is something you promised someone you would do. Usually you wouldn't PROMISE or CONTRACT with someone to not eat out.
0
;-)
0
Thanks for posting this question! I have never thought about it :)
0
Actually I made this one up myself as an example. I can say I didn’t have any story in mind when I wrote it. :)
But there definitely is a reason that these two different concepts are said in the same form in English.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
