Are these sentences okay? And which one is more natural?
The bomb has been neutralized before it went off.
The bomb has been neutralized before it detonated.
The bomb has been neutralized before it blew up.
The bomb has been neutralized before it exploded.
The bomb has been neutralized before it burst.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 7
1
Hi Nozturk, I don't like any of them really.
What's the point in saying, "before it exploded" etc AFTER you've said it's been neutralized?
You can't neutralize a bomb after it's already exploded, so you're saying the same thing twice, like when a person says, "he's very self conscious about himself" who the hell else is he going to be SELF conscious about?
I'd also use the word, "disarmed" as people seem to use it for bombs.
"The bomb/incendiary device was disarmed"
"The bomb/incendiary device had been disarmed before anyone was hurt"
"The bomb/incendiary device had been disarmed"
"The disarming of the bomb/incendiary device ensured that no one was hurt and no damage was caused".
Whatever, but I'd use the word, "disarmed" and I'd avoid saying the same thing twice, "3am in the morning" when else is there a 3am? You know? :D
KABOOM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (onomatopoeia for an explosion)
0
The bomb has been neutralized before it exploded.
0
Ah, if you changed the last word in each sentence to the present continuous tense (adding "-ing" to it), it would sound even more natural! "Before going off, before detonating, before blowing up, before exploding, before bursting." :)
0
Contrary to the top answer, all of your sentences make sense! Colloquially, sentence structures like this are used all the time. Grammatically, they're also correct, because the word/phrase after "before it", in each sentence, is used in the subjunctive tense. In other words, "before it went off" refers to a possible, or seemingly imminent outcome, not one that already happened, as was suggested in the other answer :P
The only thing that you might change would be the tense agreement between "has been" and the very last word in each sentence. The last word is in the past tense, and "has been" is in the present tense, so just make those into the same tense (has been to 'had been', or went off to 'goes off'), and it'll sound perfect :)
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
