Question about can't have done and couldn't have done
I think that he couldn’t/can't have gone abroad. I saw him just now.
In my sentences, 'I' saw him just now, so 'I' am sure that he doesn't go abroad. So 'can't have gone' should be used in this sentence, while 'couldn't have gone' used here is wrong because it states a possibility not a certainty.
Do you agree? Thank you!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 13
1
According the meaning which you are trying to express here, you should use 'couldn't have gone' and the correct sentence would be:
"I think he couldn't have gone abroad. I saw him just now."
You are right that 'couldn't have gone' shows a possibility but that i what you are trying to say. You didnt knew before seeing him that he has gone abroad or not. And you were not sure too. So that is why you said 'couldn't have gone'.
I hope it helps.
0
Both wrong! If you've just seen him then you say:
He can't have gone abroad.
I don't think he went abroad.
I doubt he went abroad.
"I think he can't have..." is just nonsense in this situation.
0
I believe you should say "I saw him just now, so I'm sure he did not go abroad". He could have gone, because he had a passport and enough money to buy a ticket. But he did not go, since I just saw him a minute ago.
0
He couldn't have gone abroad - totally correct.
Couldn't means COULD NOT HAVE GONE. What could possibly be incorrect with saying "he could not have gone, because I just saw the guy now"?
___________________________________________________________________________
I see what is happening. COULD would leave the possibility that it did not happen or may have.
Could not is not as ope ended. It simply was not possible if it could not happen.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
