How to exactly understanding "what it is they are models of"
The words was taken from Marx W. Wartofsky, a philosopher, in his article "The model muddle: Proposals for an immodest realism" (1966). It told about some puzzles of the notion of model. the completed sentence was:
"The model muddle is on which I take to be a semantic muddle -- ultimately, an ontological muddle -- regarding on the one hand the status of the entities we call models, and on the other, the status of what it is they are models of."
My understanding is that, a model has an object which is modeled (represented / described) by it, e.g. for a scale model of a car, say, the real car is the object of the model modeled. So, use this term 'object' for the sentence, it may say, in the "what it is they are models of", the 'what' is referred to the objects of the models. (Some times, what is the object of a model may be a puzzle, for examples, for the car-model, is the object of the model an instance of a car or a class of some car? for the fashion models, what is the object that she/he modeling? and so on.)
This understanding was more come from the thinking myself. However, I still have some confusion to the phrase "what it is they are models of": I don't very understanding the construction of it although it seems I know (?) the meaning...
What is the thing the word 'they' referred to?
Are there some expressions else that expressed the same meaning?
Thank you!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 2
1
You are correct: Modern English never expresses this concept well, but the phrase "what it is they are models of" refers to the object that is modeled, the modeled object. An editor should have clarified this before the article was published. :)
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
