Do you omit "being" in present perfect continuous passive?
Some textbooks say that we should, other that we shouldn't...
My feeling is that if we omit "being", the tense changes from perfect continuous to perfect, and the sense of the sentence gets lost. Let's compare:
The mall has been being built for 3 years. (= it is still being build)
The mall has been built at last. (= it has been completed)
So, whether we can / should omit "being" in the first sentence or not? ("The mall has been built for 3 years" - does it make sense?)
Thank you.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 13
3
"The mall has been built for 3 years" means that it has been completed; it was finished 3 years ago.
"The mall has been being built for 3 years" is right, but native speakers would usually say "The mall has been under construction for 3 years"
2
There is no present perfect continuous passive in English. We never use it.
They've been building it for 3 years.
You can't turn this into passive! You might say:
It's been under construction for 3 years.
1
Liza,
Of course you can use the present perfect continuous, but its complicated and inelegant structure dictates against it. Сonsider that “has been being built” uses four words to communicate what in Russian can be said in one word “строится”!
I can only think of a couple of cases where I might use it.
For example, when I am repeating someone’s exact words in order to avoid confusion.
Denis - Are you using the new bridge?
Bob - Are you kidding? It’s still being built.
Denis - What? It’s not finished yet? How long has it been “being built”?
Bob - Well, the sign says “Under Construction” -- and I haven’t seen anybody actually working on the bridge for months -- but they started it five years ago. You see, it was originally being built by a private contractor, but he went bankrupt. So for the last three years it’s been…
Denis-…being built by the city, which is also bankrupt. What a nightmare!
In this exchange the difference in meaning between the expression “ under construction” and a secondary meaning of “to build: to sponsor the construction of” is maintained.
If I were going to use it in formal writing, it would use it to express development slowly over time.
Over the last 5,000 years atomic theory has been slowly being developed by scientists into the complicated particle theory we have today.
0
Yeah, I realized it on my own after placing this example. I wish there were a possibility to remove / correct questions.
0
As you already know, stative verbs like "to be" are not normally used in the continuous tense.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
