Are they all right?
1. Tom was working in the garden while I was sitting in the sun.
1.1. Tom was working in the garden while I sat in the sun.
1.2. Tom worked in the garden while I was sitting in the sun.
2. She dropped the tray when I spoke to her.
2.1 She dropped the tray when I was speaking to her.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 11
2
They all sound all right to me. There could be some difference. Tom was working while I was sitting in the sun (the whole time), but if Tom was working in the garden while I sat in the sun, I might not have been sitting in the sun the whole time Tom had been working. If Tom worked while I was sitting, he might not have worked the whole time I was sitting.
She dropped the tray when I spoke to her seems to indicate I startled her when I spoke, and she then dropped the tray. However, If I was speaking to her, and at some point she dropped the tray, she probably was not surprised or startled when I spoke.
1
All of them are correct.
0
Sure, all of them are ok.
0
1.1. Tom was working in the garden while I sat in the sun.
She dropped the tray when I spoke to her.
根据你要表述的思想,while在这里实际上要表达相反的概念,并不是during的概念,因此1.1. Tom was working in the garden while I sat in the sun.更为合适。
作为when,动词ing的形式没有见过,因此She dropped the tray when I spoke to her.表达更好些
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
