YOU AND ME OR YOU AND I
I always hear some people said:You and me are good friends.But I think 'me' is objective case,'me' can not be used as a subject .
You and I are good friends ,I think this sentence is correct.
But I read a book,there is a sentenc in the book: Tom and me will watch a moive.
So I am confused.
Who can tell me, 'you and me are good friend' ,why no grammatical mistake in this sentence?
ps.Tom and her will go out for a date. is this sentence also correct?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 8
5
It's sloppiness, and pretty common at that. As a good English speaker, you would use "You and I" as the subject. Please, don't copy our mistakes. ;)
To stir people, whenever they say something like "You and me are good friends", or "Tom and her will go out for a date", I just reply with, "Me am a good friend?" "Her will go out for a date?"
Quite fun.
3
informally, there's nothing wrong about using you and me... there could be a very long discussion whether to use you and I or you and me.....
check out the given link below. It might be helpful:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldservice/learningenglish/youmeus/learnit/learnitv264.shtml
0
You are right in that “me” is the objective case of the pronoun and is properly used only as the object. However, these days one will often see the subjective and objective (nominative and accusative) cases of personal pronouns misused, not only I/me but also he/him and she/her. This is especially true where the pronoun is the object of a preposition.
I can see at least two reasons for such mistakes. First, in the US English grammar is not taught assiduously (勤勉地) as it was in previous generations. Perhaps this is a reflection of the training of teachers today.
To say “you and me are good friends” or ‘’Tom and her will go out on a date” simply displays an ignorance of English grammatical rules and is heard even among those who have received a college education. Some even believe that grammatical rules are simply guidelines and do not have to be observed. Perhaps this is typical of the ”do your own thing’’ generation.
Another common error is the use of the subjective case of pronouns after prepositions, as in, “he extended an invitation to John and I.”
A pronoun which is the object of a preposition is, of course, in the objective case. Perhaps this usage stems from the fact that, since using the objective form of the pronoun as a subject (you and me are good friends) is characteristic of the less educated, some people go overboard and never use the objective case. So we find such abominations (讨厌的东西, 可憎的事物) as “They are going to the concert with my husband and I.’’
The moral of this story is, “Don’t believe everything you read.”
0
thank you,your answer is so helper.
0
Here's a tip..... Remove one of the pronouns from the sentence and see how it sounds.... for example..... You and I are cool = You are cool ...... I am cool...... / He gave the food to you and me = He gave the food to you ..... He gave the food to me.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
