一句反义疑问引发的思考,希望英美国家朋友给出一个完美的答案。thanks
在新概念英语中有一篇课文,题目是A car crash.是汽车维修厂的服务员和Mr.Wood之间的对话
....
ATENDDANT : isn't that your car?
Mr.Wood: it was my car.
.......
我反复研究很多边,发现:一个简单的was 竟然蕴藏这么多的奥秘,教科书上给出 的参考译文是:“它曾经是我的车”。我对此译文疑问颇多,这种翻译给人一种错觉,(他曾经是我的车,现在不是了),如果是这种思维的话,用现在完成时(present perfect)岂不是更好。给我第一印象,更像是表达的一种婉转虚拟的的语气。记得在讲虚拟语气的侍候,好像就有was 系列的虚拟。希望英美热爱英语的人士能给出更加合理的解释。thanks!
Mr.wood: is my car ready yet?
Attendent: i don't know ,sir.
what's the number of your car?
Mr.wood: it's LFZ312G.
Attendent: when did you bring it to us?
Mr.wood: i brought it here three days ago.
Attendent: ah,yes, i remember now .
Mr.wood: have your mechanics finished yet?
Attendent: no,they're still working on it.
let's go into the garage and have a look at it.
Attendent: isn't that your car?
Mr.wood: well, it was my car.
..........
..........
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 12
0
>>> 给我第一印象,更像是表达的一种婉转虚拟的的语气。<<<
Says you - wholly erroneous, nonsensial assumption.
>>> 如果是这种思维的话,用现在完成时(present perfect)岂不是更好。<<<
Again, says you. Like, how? "It has(/n't?) been my car?" You think that'd hold water?
Grab yourself your "New Oriental" grammar books and look up the authentic "subjunctive" stuff. In stirct grammar, it is never "was". It is "were", regardless of whichever pronouns.
If you, instead of your load of sino-referencial-material-based English study, had already watched enough movies, or read enough stories, or et cetera, you wouldn't've reckoned so and you would've got perfectly used to it.
My current most-academically-notable fav movie, "Memento", for example, has some similar neat-to-English-learning-noobs lines near the ending:
Hey! It's not your car!
It is now. (Implying "it wasn't", which is the most obvious reason even idiots like me could tell)
... ... ... ...
Do I lie to myself to be happy? In your case, Teddy, yes, I will.
Is the world still out there even when I close my eyes? I have to believe...
But do I? Do I believe...? Yes. We all need mirrors to remind ourselves who we are, I'm no different.
Now... where was I?
The final monolog was of no significance per se, but put in that context, yeah, f, it was epic... yeah, f...
0
I understood you the first place. I did. But what I meant to say was also what I "directly" said at the first place. I meant that from the very beginning, right on your first comment. Yes, try more English expressing sometimes.
0
I meant a lot of British gentlemen will say "thank you" when others answer their questions, helpful or not.
0
Very funny. What is it that makes you keep thinking of, like, "含蓄的表达"? I'm telling you it ain't like what you think it's like is all; speaking of "esp the British", they start with a "thanks".
0
Here in your case, probably sarcasm. The car wash probably did the car something too "fancy" for Mr. Wood to recognize.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
