Is it a rule to use a 'wa' for a negative answer of asking the presence?(JP)
教室に椅子がありますか。
いいえ、教室の中には椅子はありません。
To answer the first sentence, can I write 'いいえ、教室の中には椅子がありません。'
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 3
0
Thank you too, Poisonous Apple. Your explanations are excellent and very helpful.
0
Yes, you can use "いいえ” to answer that question.
Although "教室の中には椅子はありません。" is gramatically correct; most of Japanese people would not use that expression. Because it sounds quite "systematic" like an answer from a robot. I think that the Japanese tend to answer just "いいえ、ありません。” or "いいえ、椅子はありません。”, or, in casual way, "いいえ、椅子はないですよ。." Though the Japanese textbooks might have demonstrated you to answer it with "ful-sentence" like you mentioned in your question. So If your question is asking whether your dialog is gramatically correct or not, then I would say yes. But if your question is asking whether your expression is common or not, I would say it is not correct.
0
(質問)
教室に椅子がありますか。
(解答)
いいえ、教室の中には椅子はありません。
いいえ、教室には椅子はありません。
いいえ、教室には椅子はありませんが、体育館にはあります。
いいえ。椅子はありませんが、机はあります。
いいえ、机しかありません。
ああ、今体育館で、その椅子を使っていますよ。(教室にはありませんが)
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
