Trouble with cases!
Hi,
I have been studying Russian for a short while and don't understand the case endings in this sentence:
Я ПРИВЕДУ С СОБОЙ ДВУХ ЧЕЛОВЕК
I will bring two people with me.
I understand the I (nominative), will bring (verb), with (preposition), myself (reflexive pronoun in instrumental) -
but the TWO I think should be in the accusative but not sure and the PEOPLE is in the nominative case here when I would expect it to be genitive (ЧЕЛОВЕКА).
I would be grateful if someone could explain to me what case each word is in, and why!
thanks in advance :)
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 9
3
You are perfectly right about 1) I being Nominative 2) with + Instrumental (с собой) construction.
Now regarding двух человек. Приведу requires Accusative, so двух here is in Accusative. (Yes, in Russian, some numbers have cases too). And двух requires Genitive, so человек is in Genitive. So here is the structure:
Verb + Number in Accusative + Noun in Genitive.
Examples:
Я нашёл трёх девушек.
Он потерял двух друзей.
Uff, it is so confusing...
2
Браво, Том! Very interesting and rather tough question. I suppose, it concerns " cardinal -collective numerals"
Два человека – cardinal numeral
двое человек – collective numeral
Сollective numerals двое, трое, четверо in the nominative-accusative rule plural form of the noun in the genitive case. Compare:
трое учеников – три ученика
четверо учеников – четыре ученика
In the other cases they agree with the noun's case: трое мальчиков – троими мальчиками
So, we can say: Я приведу с собой два человека.
But: Я приведу с собой двух человек.
Collective parallel with cardinal numerals are used with nouns that mean:
1. person in masculine gender (двое студентов – два студента)
2. nouns only in plural (кроме: двое,трое четверо. Пятеро ножниц - пять ножниц)
3. with мы, вы, они (Я приведу два человека (двух человек). С ними двумя (двоими) вы можете поговорить об этом вопросе)
1
This sentence is right.
Who? Кто? - I, Я. This is a subject, so it's in Nominative case.
And you've understood absolutely right about reflexive pronouns.
About 'двух человек':
Я приведу кого? - двух (Accusative) кого? - человек (Genitive).
Why is not 'человека'? Just because 'человека' is singular form in Genitive, so Nominative will be 'человек'. And 'человек' in this case is a plural form in the same Genitive.
You can't say 'человеки' because this is wrong. It sounds like 'persons' in English. Plural form in Nominative will be 'люди', but you can use the form 'человек' (and others forms: Dative, Instrumental and Prepositional) in plural with numeral. :)
Good luck! :)
0
That's OK Yulia, I am still learning a lot about Russian Grammar. Your answer has helped me a lot! :)
0
I'm very sorry(((, I have just reread my answer and found a mistake. In Russian we distinguish animate and inanimate nouns. "человек" – an animate noun. So in the accusative: "приведу двух (двоих) человек", "приведу два примера" (inanimate).
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
