They are monologuea. Can both (a) and (b) follow the sentences (1) to (3)?
1) He says he has the team shirt, although I've never seen him wear it.
(a) He must be telling a lie!
(b) He must have it in his closet!

(2) Although he says he has the team shirt, I've never seen him wear it.
(a) He must be telling a lie!
(b) He must have it in his closet!

(3) Although I've never seen him wear the team shirt, he says he has it.
(a) He must be telling a lie!
(b) He must have it in his closetI asked the same question before. However, I found (a) and (b) were mistaken as responses to the sentences (1) to (3). That means the answers are useless.

Question

They are monologuea. Can both (a) and (b) follow the sentences (1) to (3)?
1) He says he has the team shirt, although I've never seen him wear it. 
(a) He must be telling a lie! 
(b) He must have it in his closet! 

(2) Although he says he has the team shirt, I've never seen him wear it. 
(a) He must be telling a lie! 
(b) He must have it in his closet! 

(3) Although I've never seen him wear the team shirt, he says he has it. 
(a) He must be telling a lie! 
(b) He must have it in his closetI asked the same question before. However, I found (a) and (b) were mistaken as responses to the sentences (1) to (3). That means the answers are useless.

Answer

Yeah, A and B work fine.

I would change A to "He must be lying!" though.  "He must be telling a lie!" isn't as natural, in my opinion.  
Also, B might sound better as "It must be in his closet!".

"He must be telling a lie!" and "He must have it in his closet!" are fine, though, if that's how you want it to sound.

Answer

Well, by comparing with your previously posed question as given in,
http://www.italki.com/answers/question/79197.htm

I found that the contents are basically exactly the same, and the respondents there have already provided you the answers and suggestions. So, what is the problem, honestly?

In my personal point of view, suggestions (a) and (b) fit well into all original sentences, at least in terms of daily conversations. So, there should be no worries.
---
Good day. / 良い 一日を。

Answers · 2

Still haven’t found your answers?

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!