That or Who?
Hi all,
Can I use either of Who or That in this example?
-The man.... you bought this car from cheated you.
Note : Please reply to this as an answer not as a comment
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 12
3
Hey Noha,
In american English yes, both of these would work fine. I suspect that "who" might be slightly more grammatically correct, or even "from whom you bought this car" if you're really pulling out all the stops. "That" would likely sound more natural and modern, however.
Hope that helps!
-Peter
2
Hello Noha, If you use "from whom" then you just step out of doubts. Still, generally, "that" is used in place of an object, while who in place of a subject so using "who" here is more grammatically correct. "That" is fine too. In short, use whatever you want if you find it somehow confusing :))
2
There's one more possibility which nobody has mentioned yet.
In addition to the formal (and rather unnatural) :
-The man from whom you bought this car..
and the more usual
-The man who you bought this car from...
or the even more natural
-The man that you bought this car from..
.. there's a fourth option:
You can miss out the relative entirely and say this:
-The man you bought this car from...
When the relative clause refers to the object of the phrase, there is no need to include 'that' or 'who' at all.
1
Hello Noha!
In your sentence it would be better to use "who" - it is more natural to say: "The man who you bought this car from cheated you."
I found a simple rule to follow: when referring to a person we use "who" and when referring to an object or thing we use "that". For example: "The car that I bought is in perfect condition."
I hope that helps!
1
Both are natural, that sounds more so. In my opinion, who is preferable. I know other people are saying "from whom". I must say, only in MY opinion, this version is out-dated and used rarely. It sounds far too formal.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
