I fail to see the logic behind these sentences from a speech (historical in nature).
The following sentences are from State House Yard Speech on the Constitution
http://www.apstudent.com/ushistory/docs1751/yardcnst.htm
The President is to be chosen by electors, nominated in such manner as the legislature of each state may direct; so that if there is no legislature, there can be no electors, and consequently the office of President cannot be supplied. The Senate is to be composed of two senators from each state, chosen by the Legislature; and therefore if there is no Legislature, there can be no Senate. The House of Representatives, is to be composed of members chosen every second year by the people of the several states, and the electors in each state shall have the qualifications requisite for electors of 【the most numerous branch of the State Legislature, - unless therefore, there is a State Legislature, that qualification cannot be ascertained, and the popular branch of the Federal constitution must likewise be extinct.】 From this view then it is evidently absurd to suppose, that the annihilation of the separate governments will result from their union...
I know every word in these sentences but just don't get the logic, especially the part with 【】.
Could you please clarify the logic behind it?
For example, what is "the most numerous branch of the State Legislature"?
What is the "qualification" and why can't it be "ascertained"?
What is the "the popular branch of the Federal constitution"? And why should it "likewise be extinct" in that case?
Only when I understand the part with 【】can I comprehend why "it is evidently absurd to suppose that..."
Thank you soooooooooo much for your help :)
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 8
0
The federal House of Representatives is elected by "the people". However, which specific people had the power to elect Representatives? In early America, you usually couldn't vote if you were black, or a woman, or if you didn't own land. However, the states didn't agree on the criteria for who could vote. So, the early constitution answered the question
"Who can vote for federal representatives?"
by answering
"Anyone who can vote for the most numerous branch of a state legislature can also vote for a federal representative in the House of Representatives."
Just as the federal government has a small senate and a large house of representatives, most state legislatures (except Nebraska) also have a large chamber and a small chamber. Whoever could vote for the larger chamber in a given state could also vote for a federal representative. So, if there were no state legilatures, there would be no criteria for deciding who could vote for federal representatives.
0
Thanks a million for your help Chris!
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
