Articles
I can't inderstand one thing, I asked here about it, but anyway it is not clear to me.
I have this sentence "... so we have a problem with melting ice"
But why it is not like this "... so we have a problem with melting an ice" ( It is the same sentence, but instead of "ice" there is " an ice") maybe because it is uncountable noun? so when it is not like this "... so we have a problem with melting some ice" ( it is the same sentence, but instead of "ice" there is "some ice"), but for me this sentence isn't right, because I feel like "some ice" is only part of ice, but I would like to say what all ice are melting.
Could be noun without any article?
Thank you!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 4
1
Hi, Yasya, you appear to have successfully answered your own question. In our example, “ice” is uncountable (as it usually is), so it cannot take the indefinite article. It cannot take the definite article either, because it is not definite. Also, if we did use an article or other determiner, it could (depending on the meaning) go before the entire noun phrase “some melting (participle) ice” (= some ice that is melting), as opposed to “melting (gerund) some ice” (= the process whereby someone or something melts some ice). Finally, you are correct that “some” is a partitive, which would be most appropriate if we wanted to emphasis that we’re talking about only part of the ice that exists. To sum up, depending on whether “melting” is a participle or gerund, we could say “some melting ice” or “melting some ice”, which would in practice have about the same meaning as the ambiguous phrase “melting ice”. Let me know if my explanation cleared that up for you or not.
0
It might be because "to melt the ice" is a famous expression which means to try and create friendliness instead of animosity. So to melt ice literally is an expression which is used without "the" to somehow set apart these two meanings of "to melt (the) ice"..
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
