Question about the english passive form
Hi I need help with the passive form. In according whit the Cambridge dictionary (this website doesn't allow to me to write all the info so I paste the link: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/it/grammatica/grammatica-britannico/passive/passive):
We use the terms active voice and passive voice to talk about ways of organising the content of a clause:
Cambridge University Press published this book. (active)
This book was published by Cambridge University Press. (passive)
So, having said this, are both of the below phrases grammatically correct and if no, why? The focus is on the changes or the analysis but there is no sign of passive form.
The change brought about by online competition from amazon;
The changes brought by owners;
The analysis drawn up by interested parties;
In particular:
15 most important changes that were brought about by the Hindu Marriage;
15 most important changes brought about by the Hindu Marriage;
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 15
1
Not quite Leonardo.
"15 important changes were brought about by Hindu marriage." (complete; correct passive; not contracted)
It is the word "that" that makes a relative clause.
('that was' can be omitted in the sentences below)
"A month ago, the activity was carried out by the employee" ( this is a correct complete passive sentence)
"A month ago, the activity [that was] carried out by the employee" ( this is NOT a COMPLETE sentence, but IS a correct passive sentence fragment .
'A month ago, the activity [that was] carried out by the employee caused the entire company to shut down' (complete; correct passive)
or "A month ago, the project was implemented by the engineer" (complete ; correct passive)
with "A month ago , the project [that was] implemented by the engineer" (incomplete; correct passive fragment)
"A month ago , the project [that was] implemented by the engineer was finally completed and handed over to the marketing department." (complete ; correct passive)
1
I can see why you are confused, Leonardo, but you're missing an important point here. Look carefully at the following two clauses, and you'll see that they are actually BOTH in the passive form:
15 most important changes that were brought about by the Hindu Marriage
15 most important changes brought about by the Hindu Marriage
The second one is not active: in fact, it is the SAME as the first, just in a contracted form - "15 most important changes [that were] brought about by the Hindu Marriage". This is a reduced relative participle clause where the words 'that were' are understood.
The active form of this clause would be "15 important changes that the Hindu Marriage brought about" - where the Hindu Marriage is the subject of the sentence.
Likewise, your other examples are also passive, with the words in brackets being understood:
"The change brought about by online competition from Amazon" is a reduced form of "The change [which was] brought about by online competition from Amazon", and "The analysis drawn up by interested parties" is a reduced form of "The analysis [which was] drawn up by interested parties".
It is very common to contract relative clauses in this way, for example " 'Hamlet' is a play written by Shakespeare" or "Cheese is a product made from milk" both have reduced relative participle clauses which are the same as the ones above.
I hope that's clearer now.
0
Hi Su.Ki., I had already understood that they were all passive but I do not understand if the contracted forms, (your quote: contracted form - "15 most important changes [that were] brought about by the Hindu Marriage".) are grammatically correct , even if they do not follow the rule quoted by the Cambrige dictionary: for a sentence to the past simple = Subject + was / were + verb conjugated to the Past Participle.
0
I hope this is clearer, thanks to Merlyn's excellent explanations.
As Merlyn has explained, these are not independent sentences - they are fragments: in other words, they are just a PART of another sentence. In fact, all your examples are simply phrases - the subject or object of a longer sentence. For example, if you look at the full sentence "A month ago , the project [that was] implemented by the engineer was finally completed and handed over to the marketing department." , you'll see that it's made up of the following elements:
The project implemented by the engineer = subject
was finally completed and handed over = verb (passive - in its full form)
to the marketing department = complement/indirect object
Likewise, my simpler sentences:
Cheese = noun (subject)
is = verb
a product made from milk = noun phrase (complement)
Here's some advice - look up 'reduced relative clauses' in a good grammar book/site, and look at the examples. Do some exercises to practise. Then think of some more examples of your own. Come back here to check them, if you like.
0
Thanks Su.Ki. My problem was whit the verb into the subject "The project IMPLEMENTED by the engineer = subject". Italian grammar problem. See my comment to marlyn. Now I understand.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
