Search from various English teachers...
Vietnam flagLux
Past perfect The paragraph is part of a novel summary. I don't understand why past perfect is used in the second sentence. Shouldn't simple past be used instead? I'm asking because past perfect is about 'time up to then' but there's no reference point in the past here for the writer to jump back with past perfect. "After New York City, Arthur goes to Mexico City, to speak at a literary conference dedicated to the works of renowned writer Robert Brownburn. Arthur and Robert had had an extended romantic relationship when Arthur was in his twenties and when Robert was in his fifties. In Mexico City, Arthur is horrified to learn that he is schedule to speak alongside Marian Brownburn, Robert’s ex-wife, whom Robert had divorced after meeting Arthur."

Answers · 3

1
I think that the past event here is “going to Mexico City.” The reason the paragraph is confusing is that “goes to Mexico City” is written in the present tense — probably because it is customary, when writing about novels, to describe actions in novels in the present tense — but “going to Mexico” actually appears to be a past event.
1
No because, either way, it is clear that the relationship is long in the past due to the reference to when Arthur was in his twenties.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today