Can you give me some more examples with this sentence structure?
I've read this example in Cambridge dictionary.
"Have they any evidence to implicate him in the robbery?"
It seems weird to me as there's no participle after the verb have nor the word 'Do' is used. Is it correct to say "Do they have any evidence to implicate him in the robbery?"
And can you give me some more examples with this sentence structure? "Have sb [object] [to-inf.]"
Thank you.
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 7
3
A good question, Hilda. But as a British English native speaker, I have to say that Mohammed is only partly right about the three ways to ask this question.
In order of how common they are, the three ways are:
Do they have any evidence?
Have they got any evidence?
Have they any evidence?
"Do you have..?" is the most usual way to ask this question. This form is the most widely used construction in both American English AND British English. Don't believe anyone who tells you that 'Do you have...?' is exclusively American.
"Have you got...?" is a more informal alternative to "Do you have..?". It's more widespread in BrE than in AmE, and there's more of a sense that it's less acceptable for AmE speakers to use. But in fact, all English speakers do say "Have you got..?, especially in informal contexts. Don't believe anyone who says that "Have you got...?" is exclusively British ( or that it's gramatically incorrect!).
So what about plain "Have you...?" . Well, this is where Mohammed is wrong, I'm afraid. There is a myth out there that British people go around in their daily lives asking questions like "Have you a pen?" This is not 'British style' at all. Nobody has said this for about 100 years! You might come across it in a Victorian costume drama, but not in the real world. In fact, the only relic of this outdated construction (where 'have' as a main verb acts like 'have' as a modal or auxiliary verb, with a simple inversion for questions and addition of 'not' for the negative) is where the object includes 'any' or 'no'. So whereas you would NEVER hear a native speaker in the UK say 'Have you money?', you might hear 'Have you any money?' (to which the answer might be 'Sorry, we haven't any money' or even 'We've no money').
Just think of it as an oddity - a single exception to the general rule.
2
Hello my friend,
Talking about your question, the sentence which you wrote is based on the "British English" style and is completely correct:
British: "Have they any evidence to implicate him in the robbery?"
And also the sentence which you mentioned after that is based on the "American English" style and again is completely correct:
American: "Do they have any evidence to implicate him in the robbery?"
more examples:
*Have you a pen? / Do you have a pen?
*Have you any problem with this question? / Do you have any problem with this question?
And also friend, there's another structure which is commonly used among English speakers and that is "Have got".
*Have got = Have*
for example:
Have you got a pen?
yes, I have got(I've got) a pen.
Hope my explanations will be helpful : )
0
Hi Hilda,
As an American English native speaker, I definitely agree with Mohammad's answers and examples.
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
