Search from various English teachers...
Egypt flagMohamed
Tricky subject verb agreement Hello I am confused about the following sentences: A number of shoppers ((have/has)) complained about the price increases. Either of dentists ((is/are)) available right now. A group of people ((have/has)) registered online for the course. Neither the mother nor her children ((are/is)) going to the park. Either my children or my wife ((are/is)) happy with the house we just bought. What are the correct answers ? is there a general grammatical rule to answer these questions or it is just based on my understanding of the context ? Thanks

Answers · 9

2
(Part Two) 4. Either my children or my wife ((are/is)) happy with the house we just bought. Similar to 2, it is very strange to know that when your children are happy, your wife becomes unhappy, or your wife is happy but your children are not. It seems like your children's feelings towards the house is dependent on your wife's feelings towards the house, vice versa. If you were trying to say that both your wife and children are unhappy with the house, you can write: A: "Neither my children nor my wife [is] happy with the house we just bought." OR B: "Neither my wife nor my children [are] happy with the house we just bought." Notice that the rule of proximity is applied here again. In A, "wife" is a singular noun and is paired with a singular verb "is"; in B, "children" is a plural noun and is paired with a plural verb "are". I hope this helps you.
1
Rena's first comment is not correct. The phrase "a number of" is regarded as plural in English. Native English speakers will always say "A number of shoppers have complained." It sounds very weird the other way. If you do a Google search for "a number has or have," you'll see many discussions of this tricky problem. Your third sentence is more difficult. The answer depends a bit on what you mean by "a group." If you're talking about people who all belong to a certain group (if they're members of a club, for instance), then they count as a single unit, and "group" is treated as singular: "A group of people has registered." However, if you're simply using the word "group of people" to mean "a lot of people" or "several people" (who aren't actually members of a unified group), then "a group of people" can be treated as plural: "A group of people have registered." A better solution would be to use a different phrase, like "several people," so that there wont' be any confusion. For the sentences with "either," Rena's answers are all good.
1
Look at the MAIN NOUN A number of shoppers ((have/has)) complained about the price increases. In the sentence above, it is " A number.......". so the verb that goes with 3rd person singular is "has" Neither/either also take 3rd person singular (Neither is/has) Some of your sentences with "either" seem to be incorrect. They should be "Neither" Either of dentists ((is/are)) available right now. This should be: Either dentist is... OR Neither dentist is Neither the mother nor her children ((are/is)) going to the park. Neither the mother nor her children ARE going -- because you take the second one when there are two verbs Either my children or my wife ((are/is)) happy with the house we just bought. This needs to be NEITHER my children NOR my wife are happy.... Otherwise, it makes no sense.
1
(Part One) Hi Mohamed, 1. A number of shoppers ((have/has)) complained about the price increases. Although the phrase "A number of" seems to imply a single number, it is similar in meaning to the word "some". Edited sentence: A number of shoppers [have] complained about the price [hike]. As a side discussion, if your sentence starts with "The number of shoppers", this would mean an exact number. In this case, we would write "The number of shoppers [has]...." 2. Either of dentists ((is/are)) available right now. The word "of" is unnecessary in the sentence. I am wondering if you meant that both dentists are unavailable now. The reason is this: "Either" expresses a choice between two options: A or B. You can choose A but not B, or B but not A. Therefore, it is strange that if dentist A is available, dentist B becomes unavailable, vice versa. If you meant to say that both dentists are unavailable, you can write: "Neither dentist [is] available available right now. We use the singular verb "is" because you can think of "Neither" as "Not one". Alternatively, to save the hassle, you can simply write: "Both dentists [are] unavailable right now. 3. Neither the mother nor her children ((are/is)) going to the park. Here, the rule of proximity can be used. Use the noun or pronoun that is closer to the verb. In this case, "her children" is closer to the verb (is or are). Since "children" is a plural noun, it should be paired with a plural verb (are). Edited: Neither the mother nor her children [are] going to the park.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today