A difficult English grammar point
I started a discussion called "help! A difficult English grammar point", the link is:
https://www.italki.com/discussion/172636
I wanted to put it here, in the 'questions', but I put it in the 'discussions' because...there wasn't enough room here to write the question's details!
You can also answer me here, if you want!
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 6
0
Yes, I was really just making a comment that 'would have been' is not remotely unusual. People way it all the time in the UK, whether conditionally or reported. The guy who said it was rarely used is from the US where it may be rarely used, I don't know.
You were correct in your original post: 'Would have been' is used as it is past speculation that didn't come true. 'Will' does change to 'would' in reported speech, but 'will be' doesn't change to 'would have been'. See Type 3 conditional here: https://www.ef.co.uk/english-resources/english-grammar/conditional/
"if I had 10 million I WOULD BE rich" - "he said that if he (had - you've doubled the 'had' here which changes the meaning) had 10 million he WOULD BE (not HAVE BEEN) rich". Would doesn't change tense in reported speech. Look at the last three lines on this page: https://www.ef.co.uk/english-resources/english-grammar/tense-changes-when-using-reported-speech/
0
Kevin, sorry, maybe I misunderstood, now I'm thinking that if you know that I mentioned the verb 'WOULD HAVE BEEN' it means that you ALREADY READ my question in the 'discussions' section (because I didn't mention it here), and also the answers, so I explained to you in vain! So, you just wanted to add those things 'as an aside', just to add something. Ok, thank you!
0
Kevin, thank you for your answer, but the issue was not about the meaning of the 'conditional perfect', nor about its form. It was about "what is it exactly this 'WOULD HAVE BEEN' form in this case? What does it mean? And, since it was a 'reported speech', what is the correspondent tense, in this case, in the 'direct speech'?"
Well, it came out that in that case 'WOULD HAVE BEEN' wasn't even a 'conditional perfect', it was a 'reported form' of a 'future perfect' spoken in the past (WILL HAVE BEEN).
Thanks, anyway!
0
Would have been, the conditional perfect. You have got the answer in the discussion but I'd like to add that native speakers in the UK use it loads. Everyday conversations are littered with would have beens and many other would haves. It is often shortened to "I'd have".
I'd have been fuming if I'd heard. I'd have eaten it. She'd have jumped for joy if she'd known.
0
Jim, unfortunately I have no time now to make a summary, however my question has been already answered (I mean, I'm convinced the answer is right), however if you want to give your answer try to go to the 'discussions' section of italki (you find it by clicking on 'community' in the italki menu bar that is up on the screen, at the right of 'find a teacher'), then scroll down until you find the title 'Help! A difficult English grammar point', that's mine.
Thanks, anyway!
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
