Search from various English teachers...
United States flagAugust Ficarrotta Jr
Some て form たり questions I could use some clarification on some of the nuances between using て forms and たり form when describing things you do or did. for example when I want to say I do two things I would say. 宿題をしてシャワーを浴びます。 but what if I wanted to say this in past tense? is it 宿題をしたシャワーを浴びました。 or 宿題をしてシャワーを浴びました。 also does this infer any sort of order to the activities? I know you can say 宿題をしたりシャワーを浴びたりしていました。 however that infers that I did other things as well. I'm also curious what the difference is between the above sentence and 宿題をしたりシャワーを浴びたりしました。 Does anyone have any insight on the nuances of usage here? Thank you in advance!

Answers · 5

1
-------------------------------------------------------------------- **** Aして、Bする。 -> I did A, then did B. -「て」:a marker for 'perfection', 'done' in terms of aspect (※) - There is order of actions. A "must" happen before B. (= A then B) - A happens 1 time, B happens 1 time. - 2 senteces into 1. 「Aした」+「Bする」=Aして、Bする 例文: 「歯を磨いて、寝た」 「店に行って、本を買った」 「市役所に行って、手続きをした」 ※ 「て(た)」 can mean 'past', but It is NOT a marker for 'past'. "Done(perfection)" and "past" are different notions. All the actions taken in the past can be regarded as "things done". Then the notion of "done" genreally can cover that of "past". That's why you can say 明日は、宿題をして、シャワーを浴びるだろう This happens in the future, but you can use 'て(た)' because, again, it is a marker for 'perfection, done', not for 'past'. 'Done' can happen in the future (= 'will have been done') ※ perticle "~た" was shorten form of an old word, "たり", which means 'perfection in terms of aspect' There were markers for 'past' , such as 'き' , 'けり', which have disppeared and are no longer used in modern Japanese. -------------------------------------------------------------------- *** Aしたり、Bしたり、する Aしたり、Bしたり - means: "during a period, sometimes you do A, sometimes you do B" - The "period" is likely to be, in my opinion, longer than 30 minutes, and it can be as long as days, months, or even years. - There is no order of actions. B can happen before A. - During the period, action A and B should happen many times respectively. - It's one sentence 「Aしたり、Bしたり」をする。(=xをする)    This 'x' is 「Aしたり、Bしたり」, which is one package of some actions 例文: 「夏休みの間じゅう、私は本を読んだり散歩したり(して)、静かに過ごした」 during '夏休み(for several days)' I did [sometimes reading books, sometimes taking a walk] *** 例文: - NG:「彼が部屋に入ってきたとき、私は着替えたり本を読んだりしていた」 This sentence can be correct syntactically but semanteically not, because you cannot specify what "I" was doing when he just entered. - OK:「彼が部屋に入ってきたとき、私はちょうど着替えている最中だった」
1
When recounting a series of events, you can either use the て form or the たり form. However, there is a slight difference in meaning between them. When using the て form, you are giving a series of events that happened in the order that you gave them. For example, in the sentence you wrote: 宿題をしてシャワーを浴びます。 (I'll do my homework and then take a shower) Events must be listed chronologically. In this example, "doing homework" would be understood to come first and "showering" would occur afterward. In general, this is an account of these and only these 2 events; no other occurrences are implied by this structure. When using the past tense, the final verb will be in the past tense form: 宿題をしてシャワーを浴びました。 (I did my homework and then took a shower) When using the たり form, you are implying a range of many different events. As it would be cumbersome to list every single event, as a general rule, you list a minimum of two major events out of the set. Using your example again: 宿題をしたりシャワーを浴びたりしていました。(I was doing my homework and taking a shower (among other things)) Since your final verb is in the past-progressive form, you are indicating that the events occurred during another particular event. For example: あなたが着いた時、私は宿題をしたりシャワーを浴びたりしていました。 In your other example: 宿題をしたりシャワーを浴びたりしました。(I did my homework and took a shower (among other things)) This is simple a statement of the events that occurred in the past. The たり form does not imply a specific order in the events; it simply recounts the main events and implies everything else. Does this make sense? I think I have answered all of your questions, but let me know if anything is still unclear and I will try to clarify what I am talking about. Good luck in your studies!

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today