Search from various English teachers...
China flagElinor
this is a multiple choice The ? in Dan 's character has hindered him from advancing in his career. the ?should be A.weakness B.shortcoming C.demerit D.defectthis choice exam comes from my English test,the answer is" D defect",i do not know why?

Answers · 3

1
Ni hao xiaoxiao, The words : defect , shortcoming , weakness ,demerit in general refer to faults , deficiencies and imperfections, but when related to character in your specific context as a hindrance to advancement in one's career then : - When you use " weakness" you are not determining the shortcoming or defect in particular , it is more of a general term that could refer to more than one flaw , that result in a weak character.The weakness in character reflects different features and conducts that constitute that state. -The shortcoming or defect is referring specifically to a certain flaw or flaws in the character.It points those flaws more specifically. Accordingly "weakness" would be a more general term to use in this context ( in relation to character), while "shortcoming" and "defect" would be more specified and would refer more to those deficiencies resulting from the weakness in character . -"Demerit" on the other hand means lack of merit due to those defects or shortcomings. The term is not usually associated to character, but to those deficiencies causing loss of privilege or deserving no merit. In your example in particular I think weakness is more related to character traits ( e.g hesitancy, hastiness) that would possibly result in shortcomings and defects in career -related skills and qualifications ( weak computer skills, incompetent marketing skills,etc) and it would manifest itself in demerits like ( inaccuracy,inefficiency,etc). Nevertheless the context is very important to determine the word you are using here. Reading the whole paragraph would help a lot in deciding which one to use. I hope I didn't confuse you :) because i am ;)
0
while all four choices can be considered somewhat synonymous as they pertain to flaws, the only clear choice is D. defect. since no two words have exactly the same meaning, in order to answer correctly, you must fully understand the subtle nuances of each of those terms and their respective usages. in my own terms, a defect is a flaw having a deleterious effect on the whole of something. and in the sentence provided, Dan fails to advance his career due to a character flaw. so as you can see this “defect” has essentially kept him from getting a promotion and therefore, substantively fitting perfectly into the scheme of this particular sentence. having a weakness in character essentially means someone is weak. and being weak does not address the matter sufficiently by virtue of the generic nature of its definition. while a shortcoming shares the same principal meaning it does not fit the wording of that sentence because a shortcoming basically means a character flaw. Since you cannot have a “character flaw” in someone’s character (making it redundant), you can also rule that one out. leaving only demerit which is simply absurd to use here. again D. defect is the only correct option here. let me know if you have any further questions. as an aside, to maximize your success on these types of english examinations, it’s best that you not merely memorize hundreds of definitions but also be familiar with how those words are used in the contexts of sentences. 加油! :)
0
hi xiaoxiao, I think all of the choices can be used but, i think it isn't appropriate to use "weakness" as the right word for it. We could perhaps use the term "weakness" if it has something to do with someone's ability to perform or with the lacking of physical & mental strength. "demerit" on the other hand can also be applied but in my point of view, "shortcoming" fits best, as we are speaking here Dan's inadequateness or insufficiency upon advancing in his career. I stand corrected on this.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today