Search from various English teachers...
Bangladesh flagMamun Hossen
Please, help me understand this. The doctor, _______ saw me in the morning, insisted that I should quit smoking. A) who B) that I took this question from a website, which helped me a lot understand grammar. (EnglishGrammar dot org) Here the answer is option A according to that source. There was explained "Both who and that can refer to people; however, we cannot use that in non-identifying relative clauses. Here the commas indicate that the relative clause is non-identifying." But one of my friends said "it's a defining relative clause.We do not need to use a comma here. That and who both can be used if you remove the comma." Actually, I don't have much idea about identifying and non-identifying relative clauses. Could you please help me understand them? It would be very appreciated. Thanks!

Answers · 4

1
Hello Mamun, Yes here we are talking about the difference between defining and non-defining relative clauses. These can get a little complicated but I will give you a basic summary. DEFINING RELATIVE CLAUSES -no commas -give essential information for the listener or reader to understand the noun/noun phrase you are referring to - who or that can be used to refer to people EXAMPLE: -My brother is the man who is wearing the blue shirt. -My brother is the man that is wearing the blue shirt. (Without the information about the blue shirt you wouldn't know which man my brother is, so the relative clause is defining, or essential) NON-DEFINING RELATIVE CLAUSES -commas -give extra, non-essential information about the noun you are referring to -that cannot be used EXAMPLE: My friend, who is a doctor, is moving to London. (The relative clause 'who is a doctor' is extra, non-essential information. The sentence would still make sense without it. Therefore it is non-defining.) I hope this helps. Let me know if you have any more questions. Christine
1
Its better to keep it simple Mamun. If the person being discussed is a person then we use "who" so in the case of "the Doctor who....." who will always be correct. That is used where the thing is not a person. For Example: "the dog that ate my shoe...." It gets complicated with other sentences like "the dog that ate my shoe is dead now". compared to "the doctor that parked in my space, his car has been removed" In this example you can see who or that would be acceptable. I hope it helps.
1
As a native english speaker myself, if you said "the doctor that saw me this morning" or "the doctor who saw me this morning" I would understand either way. If you remove the comma then either one is correct. I don't really understand why it is that B would be incorrect. It makes sense both ways.
1
From a grammatical standpoint, it should be "who" but if we're just talking about everyday English, you wouldn't get any funny looks if you said "The doctor that saw me."

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today