Search from various English teachers...
China flagElaine
How should I analy this sentence structure? Hello, everyone! Thanks for reading my question. Please help me figure it out. Thank you very much! I'm reading « Staring at the sun», a book written by Irvind. Yalom. This book is about death anxiety and how to confront it. Here is a context of it. "For other people,the anxiety is louder,unruly,tending to erupt at three in the morning,leaving them gasping at the specter of death. They are besieged by the thought that they,too, will soon be dead--as will everyone around them." This is my understanding: death anxiety erupts differently. Some people easily experience and recognize it . They may wake up at three in the morning, realized they were surrounded by the horror of death, knew that they will die sooner or later, people around them will be dead too .I think I get most of it,but I am confused by the structure of last sentence. "They are besieged by........" please help me to analyze it. Thanks!

Answers · 3

1
Irvin Yalom has contributed so much to the field of existential psychotherapy. I have read much of his written work and have a deep respect for him. In the case of being besieged in this context, I see it as surrounded and oppressed, or held captive, by the fear and anxiety of death. To be besieged in battle is to be surrounded and captive. It is one reality faced by many people in all cultures: "fear of running out of time." Early psychoanalysts such as Freud saw a relationship between death anxiety and neurosis (although neurosis is an outdated term mostly).
0
I'm far from an expert, but to me, if you suddenly wake in fear in the early hours, that probably suggests that you _haven't_ recognised that you are suffering anxiety? Recognising that you have an anxiety is perhaps the first step to conquering it? I think that 'erupts differently' is probably not a good phrase to use either. 'Erupts' is a violent word, and to me suggests the most terrifying end of the spectrum of responses. He uses /loud/unruly/erupt to emphasise that violent nature.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today