Search from various English teachers...
China flagFolia Green
Is it right to say "Have you been in Beijing thirty years ago?"? There's a person who spent some time in Beijing 30 years ago. Someone wants to know if he stayed there for some time. Is it right to say "Have you been in Beijing thirty years ago?"? Or "Were you in Beijing for some time 30 years ago?" Thanks.

Answers · 6

1
It would be best to say something like, "Were you in Bejing 30 years ago?" or "When you were in Bejing 30 years ago, how long were you there for?"
0
The simple past is necessary, because we are talking a completed action in the past: "Were you in Beijing 30 years ago?" If the person is still in Beijing, you can say, "Have you (really!) been in Beijing for 30 years?"
0
I agree with Olivia, Is it right to say "Have you been in Beijing thirty years ago? No, this is not correct, I recommend saying: Were you in Beijing 30 years years ago? Were you in Beijing for some time 30 years ago? This is a correct way to ask, although can be better. Were you in Beijing 30 years ago, how long were you there?
0
"Were you in Beijing for some time thirty years ago?" is a correct and understandable sentence. It might be answered - - Yes, I lived there for three years. Sadly, since I'm only thirty-four years old now, I don't remember it very clearly." or - No. In 1987, I was only in Beijing for a few hours while changing trains. It wasn't until 2003 that I was able to spend a few months there.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today