Search from various English teachers...
Johnny
Questions about two very difficult ACT Grammar sentences I have two very confusing sentences here. I've asked my friends, who are native speakers, about these sentences, but they didn't know which options are correct or why they are correct.....Which options would you consider correct and why? (I put the differences between options in two stars*) 1. (Option 1) The Maui Chamber of Commerce petitioned Congress, asking that a serious effort be made*,* to save the plant. (Option 2) The Maui Chamber of Commerce petitioned Congress, asking that a serious effort be made to save the plant. 2. (Option 1) *Using* irreverent wit and satire, their protests have motivated many people to consider choosing a career in an artistic field. (Option 2) *For use of* irreverent wit and satire, their protests have motivated many people to consider choosing a career in an artistic field.

Answers · 10

2
I agree with Chris: Q1: option 2. Q2: option 1. In both cases, I picked an answer quickly and was pretty sure about it--but find it hard to explain why. In question 1, option 1 might be just plain incorrect; but I think it is possible that it could be a correct but awkward way to express an unlikely meaning. I can concoct an example in which something like option 1 would be correct. "...asking that a serious effort be made, not to stop all commercial development in the area, but to save the plant. In any case, option 2 is definitely correct, while option 1 is probably incorrect, so, as an experienced test-taker, I know what to do. In question 2, option 1 makes sense and option 2 doesn't. I can't even figure out a meaning for option 2. Option 1 might be easier to understand if we order the sentence, "Their protests, using irreverent wit and satire, have motivated many people to consider choosing a career in an artistic field." That makes sense, and "Their protests, for use of irreverent wit and satire," doesn't--unless it means that the protesters are protesting _somebody else's_ satire. We might use the phrase "for use of irreverent wit and satire" in a sentence like this: "The autocratic government threw the protesters in jail for use of irreverent wit and satire." We could also use this word order, "For use of irreverent wit and satire, the autocratic government threw the protesters in jail."
1
1. Option 2 is correct. "To save the plant" is an infinitive phrase--it's not a complete clause by itself, so it shouldn't be separated with a comma 2. Option 1 is correct.

Still haven’t found your answers?

Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today