Why is there a "by"?
The study suggests that the cultures we grow up in influence the basic processes by which we see the world around us.
In the above sentence, why is there a "by"? How to analyze the grammar of this sentence?
Search from various English teachers...
Answers · 6
2
Examine this easier sentence:
We see the world around us BY these basic processes. <-- Here, the word "by" indicates the means one uses to accomplish something.
To turn this sentence into a noun phrase using a relative clause, we do the following:
1.) take the part after the preposition "by" and move it to the front:
=> THESE BASIC PROCESSES we see the world around us by
2.) add the relative pronoun "which" between the two of them:
=> these basic processes WHICH we see the world around us by
3.) move the preposition "by" before "which":
=> these basic processes BY WHICH we see the world around us
This is what is happening in the fragment of your sentence. I hope this helps. :)
"These basic processes by which we see the world around us" can also be expressed as "these basic process that/which we use to see the world around us". Notice how I had to insert "use to" between "we" and "see" though. This is done to retain the "by means of" relationship expressed by "by" in the original sentence.
2
"By + which" in this context is a preposition + relative pronoun which introduces a relative clause. That combination means basically "of how." It is saying that our processes influence how we see the world.
I hope that helps!
Still haven’t found your answers?
Write down your questions and let the native speakers help you!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
